The Fault in Our Stars (2012) - Book by John Green
* * * *
After
hearing so much about this book I have finally managed to read it. I
wasn't expecting it to be as good as everyone has been saying because,
although I love the Vlogbrothers channel, I am not a fan of John Green's
writing. I was very pleasantly surprised because not only was the book
enjoyable but I was quickly drawn in and had a strong desire to keep
reading even at 3am. In case you have only just acquired the internet,
it is a story about a young girl, Hazel Grace, who is dying from cancer
and her encounter with the metaphor loving Augustus Walters.
The
story is very hard-hitting because it is about such a terrible topic
and anyone would well-up during reading. Sadly I was not overly
interesting in Augustus, I dislike pretension and he was quite
self-admittedly a pretentious character. The moments that affected me
the most were the points where the parents were speaking to Hazel and
dealing with losing their daughter. These sections were written very
well, possibly because John is a father, and made me feel very
emotional. The reader can sympathise with all those affected by the
cancer, those physically suffering and the others who are close to them.
The
characters were good. Teenage girls written by men are normally awful
but Hazel Grace was quite normal, believable and likeable. The adults
were quite perfect and very parent-like, familiar to all who were
reading. The friends, however, were slightly mixed. Isaac, a fellow
cancer patient was funny and likeable whereas Kaitlyn, a school friend
of Hazel's, is quite clichéd as an over-dramatic secondary friend.
After
finishing the book didn't resonate with me the way it has seemed to
with so many other people but it really isn't the genre that I enjoy. It
was well written and enjoyable and I hope that the film does it
justice. I'm glad that John Green has written a book that I enjoy
because I feel like a better Nerd Fighter but I worry that the other Nerd
Fighters promoting it so strongly has diminished my enjoyment of the
book because nothing was a surprise.
Reviewing films and TV (sometimes other things) while doing a degree in Film and Literature. Find me elsewhere on Twitter: @SkruffReviews Blogspot: http://skruffreviews.blogspot.co.uk/ Wordpress: http://skruffreviews.wordpress.com/
Showing posts with label Book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book. Show all posts
Thursday, 19 September 2013
Monday, 2 September 2013
Howl's Moving Castle (1986) - Book by Diana Wynne Jones
* * * *
The book that sparked the famous Studio Ghibli movie was one of my childhood reads and after I realised that I knew the film version better than the original I thought that I had better reread it. Despite the same title the book and the film are actually very different stories, both equally good for their respective mediums.
The magical realm is created wonderfully as new magical characters or items are introduced slowly through the narrative. The fact that one of the strongest characters in the book is a fire demon name Calcifer shows how Diana Wynne Jones can deftly combine the normal with the extraordinary.
Diana's story is slightly different, following more characters and resolving things differently.
Personally I felt as though there were too many characters and in the final chapter was quite confused with who all the different people were. I think the writers of the film must have either felt the same way or decided that too many characters would cause the story to extend beyond the traditions 1.5-2 hours for children films. Either way their decision to remove a few unnecessary characters aided the story.
Only having read the first book, although there are 3 more, left me with a feeling of dissatisfaction because it ends quite abruptly. The final chapter contains everything and it becomes very rushed and simply ends. Another chapter or a epilogue, though quite extravagant for a children's book, would be helpful just to ease the reader out of the world.
Although it is a very quick and easy read for most adults and despite the flaws that I can pick in the book it is still a very worthwhile read because of the magnificent story, writing and characters which work together to create an entertaining book deserved of such a great film.

The book that sparked the famous Studio Ghibli movie was one of my childhood reads and after I realised that I knew the film version better than the original I thought that I had better reread it. Despite the same title the book and the film are actually very different stories, both equally good for their respective mediums.
The magical realm is created wonderfully as new magical characters or items are introduced slowly through the narrative. The fact that one of the strongest characters in the book is a fire demon name Calcifer shows how Diana Wynne Jones can deftly combine the normal with the extraordinary.
Diana's story is slightly different, following more characters and resolving things differently.
Personally I felt as though there were too many characters and in the final chapter was quite confused with who all the different people were. I think the writers of the film must have either felt the same way or decided that too many characters would cause the story to extend beyond the traditions 1.5-2 hours for children films. Either way their decision to remove a few unnecessary characters aided the story.
Only having read the first book, although there are 3 more, left me with a feeling of dissatisfaction because it ends quite abruptly. The final chapter contains everything and it becomes very rushed and simply ends. Another chapter or a epilogue, though quite extravagant for a children's book, would be helpful just to ease the reader out of the world.
Although it is a very quick and easy read for most adults and despite the flaws that I can pick in the book it is still a very worthwhile read because of the magnificent story, writing and characters which work together to create an entertaining book deserved of such a great film.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)